proheart 12 injection killed my dog

Dogs 12 months of age and older may receive ProHeart 12 every 12 months. ProHeart is a prescription medication used to prevent heartworm disease in dogs. Despite the many benefits of the ProHeart injection, it is important to note that it is not suitable for every dog. According to the current manufacturer, Zoetis, since the reintroduction, adverse reactions are rare and usually not serious. From 12 months of age an annual preparation given by injection can be administered to protect against heartworm. The product information provided in this site is intended only for residents of the United States. gastrointestinal, dermatologic and hematologic), Gastrointestinal: vomiting (with or without blood), diarrhea with or without blood, hypersalivation, General: depression, lethargy, anorexia, fever, weight loss, weakness, Dermatological: injection site pruritus/swelling, erythema multiforme, Neurological: seizures, ataxia, trembling, hind limb paresis, Hematological: leukocytosis, anemia, thrombocytopenia, Respiratory: dyspnea, tachypnea, coughing, Hepatic: elevated liver enzymes, hypoproteinemia, hyperbilirubinemia, hepatopathy, Urinary: elevated BUN, elevated creatinine, hematuria, polydipsia, polyuria andcardiopulmonary signs such as coughing and dyspnea may occur in heartworm-positive dogs. Plus get new recipes delivered right to your inbox. However, it contains moxidectin the same active ingredient that is found in ProHeart 6 at a higher dosage. Treatment every three months should be effective no matter where you live. Unknown long-term effects: The long-term effects of ProHeart on pets are unknown, which makes it difficult to predict the potential risks associated with the medication. Data on file. This disease can be very serious and left untreated could result in the death of your pet. On November 12, he lost his balance, had two seizures and he died that evening at an emergency veterinary clinic, going into cardiac arrest while having a blood transfusion and while I was holding him. Heartworms have become an epidemic all over the world, with the majority of them found in the United States. There are other drugs available and this one is not worth the risk., This drug can cause liver failure, seizures, and death. Injections lasting 12 months are more expensive but last longer than the others. I wish I knew this 8 months ago. Check out this Facebook post by one North Carolina clinic , FINALLY! My female mixed breed rescue dog had her annual check up. In growing puppies, a couple of boosters are required (one at 12 weeks of age, another at 6 months, and then again around 12 months of age) but after this, the injection is yearly. Rhett Burch. Dec 20, 2021 - ProHeart injection is a popular heartworm prevention product manufactured by Zoetis. What are the first signs of heartworms in dogs? Also Read: Baytril killed my dog Is Baytril toxic to dogs? ProHeart 12 is indicated for use in dogs 12 months of age and older and ProHeart 6 is indicated for use in dogs 6 months of age and older. No one needs to endure what we are. ProHeart 12 is currently the only FDA-approved heartworm prevention product that prevents heartworm disease for a full year. Can ProHeart kill heartworms? Talk with your veterinarian to see if your dog is a good candidate. Is ProHeart 12 Safe? Other potential side effects include diarrhea, lethargy, anorexia, and weight loss. My dog got his ProHeart injection this morning. Any dog that routinely gets out and kills people's cats. I told the vet he wasn't right after the Proheart 6. Proheart Injection for Dogs Side Effects The Proheart injection is a new, long-acting heartworm preventive that provides protection against heartworms for up to six months. Moxidectin is a drug used to treat parasitic infections in dogs, cats, and large farm animals. Lack of effective warning label: The manufacturer of ProHeart failed to adequately warn pet owners of the potential risks and side effects associated with the medication. Do not administer to dogs that are sick, debilitated, underweight, have a history of weight loss, or to those previously found to be hypersensitive to the drug . Lets start with the most important question: ProHeart 12 Injection is a veterinary medication used to treat heartworm in dogs. No, Capstar cannot hurt your dog. If your dog experiences any severe side effects or if the side effects do not improve within a few days, contact your veterinarian for further advice. The ProHeart 6 and ProHeart 12 web-based training and certification module is available at http://www.proheart6.com. proheart 12 injection killed my dog. ProHeart 12 is indicated for use in dogs 12 months of age and older for the prevention of heartworm disease caused by Dirofilaria immitis for 12 months. It was a timed-release medication basically, you injected a blob of medicine under the skin and it slowly leached into the bloodstream for the next six months. Proheart SR-12 Injection Small Be the first to review this product Proheart SR-12 Small SKU 9347909003550 $529.90 Pet's Name VetRx ID (if using VetRX) Prescription Status Upload New Prescription Compatible file extensions to upload: pdf, png, jpg, jpeg Qty Add to Cart Add to Compare We will aim to dispatch this product within 1-2 Business days. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. ProHeart is the only injectable heartworm preventatives available for long-term use. Vetoryl Killed My Dog Can Vetoryl Kill My Dog? Ask your vet for more information. Other side effects were: The FDA Doctor who realized the dangers of ProHeart 6 was taken off the case and criminally prosecuted. If contact with the eyes occurs, rinse thoroughly with water for 15 minutes and seek medical attention immediately. Because puppies grow rapidly, they tend to need different dosages of heartworm preventative each month, based upon their weight. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. However, the safety of concurrent . There may be coughing, decreased appetite and stamina, or depression in your dog. It is a highly effective method of preventing this potentially deadly disease, which is transmitted by mosquitos. According to the vet, the shot was safe and effective. Comment * document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "aa6a33319a3fb411923a23192f189adc" );document.getElementById("ae31964646").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The product label for ProHeart 12 cites an alarmingly long list of adverse events of ProHeart 6. Julia Henriques is Managing Editor of Dogs Naturally Magazine. I really appreciate your time. The ProHeart 12 injection works similarly to ProHeart 6, but instead of providing heartworm protection for six months, it will last a whole year. Ingestion of large quantities of this can be fatal to dogs. ProHeart is not effective against existing heartworm infections. She was such an important part of our family and we miss her dearly. Proheart is an INJECTABLE heartworm prevention that is only given every 6 months! There are lots of safer ways to prevent heartworm. In light of these risks, the manufacturer voluntarily withdrew ProHeart from the market. At the time of the shot, ProHeart 12 also treats hookworms. With ProHeart, monthly dosing is eliminated and continuous protection is provided. This is the last paragraphAustralian Vets often give this injection at the SAME time as vaccinations ;) ProHeart 6 is generally well tolerated. 2022 - Dogs Naturally Magazine Inc. These can include swelling, redness, or tenderness at the injection site. ProHeart 12 injection has proven to be safe and worthwhile! A dog whose breed is known to be sensitive should be given special care when taking any medication containing moxidectin. Learn more here. ProHeart SR-12 Injection is a once-a-year product for the prevention of heartworm disease in dogs. Most of these reactions disappear on their own within several days. Pricing. Use ProHeart 6 in dogs 6 months of age or older and ProHeart 12 in dogs 12 months of age or older. In rare cases, more serious adverse reactions have been reported including seizures, muscle tremors, and difficulty walking. To find a holistic or homeopathic vet near you or to find one who will do phone consultations, visit The Academy Of Veterinary Homeopathy or the American Holistic Veterinary Medical Association. Heartworm can affect dogs and is spread by mosquitoes. A number of different parasites can be treated with Moxidectin, which is available in oral, topical, and injectable forms. These reactions are usually mild and resolve on their own within a few days. ProHeart, a brand of heartworm preventative medication, has been the subject of much controversy and criticism in the veterinary community. It is important to discuss the suitability of the ProHeart injection with your veterinarian before administering it to your dog. Especially if she thinks youre forgetful. Anaphylactic and anaphylactoid reactions can result in death and should be treated immediately with the same measures used to treat hypersensitivity reactions to vaccines and other injectable products. The information, including but not limited to, text, graphics, images and other material contained on this website are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Owner / veterinarian. I am including a link to a Facebook page that has many stories of dogs dying after being given this shot (and others who are having serious reactions). AHS Canine Guidelines 2020. https://d3ft8sckhnqim2.cloudfront.net/images/pdf/2020_AHS_Canine_Guidelines.pdf?1580934824, accessed 1/27/21. The Convenia rewards depends on the dose based weight of the dog, starting at twenty pounds. There have also been reports of vomiting and diarrhea. Weve already seen some horrified reactions from holistic vets we know: I cannot believe this was approved. Two months later (and many vet trips) he started experiencing chronic diarrhea. It is best to speak with your veterinarian about the risks before giving your dog this medication. These spheres contain moxidectin, the active ingredient. Caused by Dirofilaria immitis. DOSAGE AND ADMINISTRATION Do not administer to dogs that are sick, debilitated, underweight, have a history of weight loss, or to those previously found to be hypersensitive to the drug. How much does ProHeart 12 typically cost? At Eastwaye Veterinary Clinic, we are proud to offer our patients the ProHeart 6 and ProHeart 12 heartworm preventatives. Effective at preventing heartworm infection: Proheart is highly effective at preventing heartworm infection in dogs when given as directed. Simply forgetting to give your dog these monthly preventatives is the primary factor that contributes to the increase in heartworm cases, according to the American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA). ProHeart 6 and ProHeart 12 are for use in dogs only and are available through a restricted distribution program to veterinarians that have completed the RiskMAP training and certification module. The shots hes had have never caused a reaction in him, and weve never had an issue with him getting heartworms. Many pet owners are concerned that ProHeart injections will kill their dogs. PH 12 was first registered in Australia in late 2000 and became the top-selling heartworm preventative, with 47% market share by January 2005, due to its . Tonight, we had to put him down because of the GI issues which became so painful it put him into shock and he wouldnt walk. Here in Australia we have Proheart 12 which is a 12 month injection & is 3 times the dosage of the Proheart 6 - (6 monthly) one that was recalled ;) Proheart site. It can also treat hookworms at the time of injection. If you suspect that your dog has received an overdose of Proheart, contact your veterinarian immediately. Symptoms such as labored breathing, fainting spells, or sudden death may occur as the disease progresses. The only problem I have is the price of ProHeart 6 which has risen significantly in recent years.. Zoetis. ProHeart 12 is the only FDA-approved product that prevents heartworm disease in dogs for 1 full year with just 1 shot given by your vet. Please support the hard working holistic vets who make this information possible. Lichtenfels et al. Proheart is a brand of medication that contains the active ingredient moxidectin, which is used to prevent heartworm infection in dogs. When possible, avoid moxidectin medications in breeds that are known to be sensitive. Hypersensitivity reactions may occur in some dogs when ProHeart is administered alone or with vaccines. When it was reintroduced, all the doctors had to go through a webinar before they could prescribe it. We took her to the vet, and they administered the shot with no problems. More severe disease can also be successfully treated, but the possibility of complications is greater. If you notice any side effects, call your veterinarian immediately. On average, the price of a ProHeart 12 shot is about the same as 12 months worth of a monthly heartworm disease preventative. Reported side effects in clinical trials included vomiting, lethargy, diarrhea, anorexia, and hypersensitivity reactions. If that test also shows a positive result, your vet will talk with you about a treatment plan. The once a year injection provides the following benefits:- eliminates the need to remember monthly heartworm tablets No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment of your pet. Those who did encounter problems report that their dogs symptoms disappeared within 24 hours of using the product, and they would repurchase it because it is so effective at preventing heartworm infection. Its active ingredient On behalf of all the dogs who have died from this drug, I am writing this letter. (And, in case you missed it theres 3 times as much moxidectin in ProHeart 12 as Proheart 6 so side effects are likely to be greater. ProHeart 12 lasts for 12 months, while Heartgard only lasts for 1 month. In addition to vomiting and diarrhea, symptoms of moxidectin toxicity include lethargy, disorientation, and lethargy. ProHeart 12 can be used in healthy dogs that are one year or older. ProHeart 12 also has a slightly higher efficacy rate than Heartgard 96% vs 90%. The solution has come in the form of heartworm prevention shots that protect your dog for six months or a full yearProHeart 6 and ProHeart 12. All decisions regarding the care of a veterinary patient must be made with an animal healthcare professional, considering the unique characteristics of the patient. It is also worth noting that heartworm disease itself can be life-threatening if left untreated, so preventing it is crucial for the health and well-being of dogs. The Coraxis that I apply monthly is stinky, messy and gross for about 24 hours. Some dogs also experienced injection site inflammation. ProHeart injections are a superior alternative to oral heartworm preventative medications because they are fail-safe. And so are several holistic veterinarians. The vet also highly recommends it. * ProHeart 12 is for use in healthy dogs 12 months of age and older. Please dont risk this medicine on your dog. How do I switch from another heartworm disease preventative to ProHeart 12? The vet didnt know the cause of the original attack. She never had any health problems before that shot and was full of life up until the last day., My dog, a golden retriever named Finn, went to the vet for his yearly checkup on January 20. However, as with any medication, there are potential side effects that you should know. With canine heartworm infections being reported in all 50 states in the US, heartworm prevention is essential. Metacam killed my dog How much Metacam is toxic to dogs? While ProHeart 12 is new to hit the market in the USA, it has been marketed and usedheavilyin Australia for 19 years. ProHeart injection is one option for preventing heartworm disease and can be an effective choice when used as directed by a veterinarian. Dogs treated with ProHeart 12 (T02) received a single SC dose (0.5 mg/kg moxidectin) as per label on day . We were told she has a food allergy. Dogs with no signs or mild signs of heartworm disease, such as cough or exercise intolerance, have a high success rate with treatment. You cant get any easier than that! Heartworm disease is serious and potentially fataland a single bite from an infected mosquito can cause it in your dog. ProHeart 12, a moxidectin extended-release injectable formulation for prevention of heartworm (Dirofilaria immitis) disease in dogs in the USA for 12 months. The symptoms can last for a week or longer in some cases. ProHeart 12 is a monthly heartworm preventative for dogs that is administered as an injection by your veterinarian. 125 Satisfied Customers. There have been reports of allergic reactions when ProHeart 6 and vaccines have been given together. This product is great! It is safer, lasts longer, and is much easier to administer than other heartworm treatments. If you suspect your dog is experiencing an allergic reaction, seek medical attention immediately. He worked as a livestock officer for two years in an NGO, and since then he has been practicing pet animals medicine privately. ProHeart 12 Dosage And Administration Dogs receiving PROHEART 6 should be tested for existing heartworms as per the product label. ProHeart 6 was taken off the market in 2004 because of concerns about safety. Were fighting for her life all over again all because of a drug that is SUPPOSEDLY safe. And based on the outrage online, I think the number of rare cases arent actually rare as much as not the majority., Its certainly more common than theyre implying. Adverse reactions: Many dogs experienced severe reactions to ProHeart, including vomiting, diarrhea, loss of appetite, and lethargy. Do not administer to dogs that are sick, debilitated, underweight, have a history of weight loss, or to those previously found to be hypersensitive to the drug. FDA Approves Potentially Deadly ProHeart 12, Why I Dont Give My Dogs Heartworm Meds (And Why You Shouldnt Either), Restricting the drug to veterinarians trained and certified in its use, Requiring informed consent by dog owners before treatment, Adding more safety and risk information to the product label, Setting criteria for dogs to qualify for treatment, Eliminating residual solvents in the product that may have contributed to the adverse effects. ProHeart-6 was given by injection once every six months. The medicine is then released evenly over 1 years time, keeping your buddy consistently protected from heartworms. approved by the US Food & Drug Administration, How to Keep Small Dogs Healthy, From Puppy to Senior Dog, 12 Ways to Protect Your Dogs Paws All Year Round, Why You Need to Stay Current on Flea, Tick, and Heartworm Protection. The content on this website is not meant to replace veterinary advice. Initial symptoms of heartworm disease are generally non-specific and can mimic those of other diseases. He holds an MS in Pharmacology from Bangladesh Agricultural University and a DVM from the same institution. Dog shelters will typically euthanize pets that are positive for parvo, just because of the risk of . ProHeart 6 is a heartworm prevention shot that lasts six months ($50 to $150 per six months), and ProHeart 12 is a shot that is given annually ($75 to $350 per year). To supplement the pre-approval safety evaluation for ProHeart 12, the FDA reviewed voluntarily-reported adverse event data from foreign markets, including . You need to know more about it before you run to your vet for a prescription. May cause side effects: Some dogs may experience side effects after receiving Proheart, including vomiting, diarrhea, loss of appetite, lethargy, and allergic reactions. The drug is already in your dog for 12 months (or probably longer). : //www.proheart6.com eyes occurs, rinse thoroughly with water for 15 minutes and seek medical attention immediately vomiting! Effective no matter where you live replace veterinary advice ingestion of large quantities of this can be administered to against! Fighting for her life all over the world, with the majority of them found in the United States,! Several days symptoms of moxidectin toxicity include lethargy, anorexia, and website in browser. Spells, or sudden death may occur in some dogs when given as directed by a veterinarian training and module... Usa, it has been the subject of much controversy and criticism in the death of your pet Canine! Rewards depends on the dose based weight of the original attack injections lasting 12 months SR-12 injection is a medication! Post by one North Carolina clinic, we are proud to offer our patients the ProHeart injection, it moxidectin... And usually not serious dogs who have died from this drug, I am writing letter... A positive result, your vet will talk with your veterinarian about the same as 12 months of age older... Dog is a popular heartworm prevention product that prevents heartworm disease for a full year every dog Convenia rewards on! Been marketed and usedheavilyin Australia for 19 years //d3ft8sckhnqim2.cloudfront.net/images/pdf/2020_AHS_Canine_Guidelines.pdf? 1580934824, accessed 1/27/21 when given as by! To your inbox and website in this browser for the next time I comment toxic to dogs and! The prevention of heartworm preventative each month, based upon their weight is Managing Editor of dogs Naturally Magazine disease... Weve never had an issue with him getting heartworms result in the US, heartworm prevention is.. Convenia rewards depends on the dose based weight of the dog, starting at twenty pounds an effective when. Seizures, muscle tremors, and they administered the shot with no problems: I can not believe was. Facebook post by one North Carolina proheart 12 injection killed my dog, we are proud to offer our patients the ProHeart and... And usually not serious their dogs more severe disease can also be successfully,. No problems only problem I have is the price of ProHeart 6 was taken off the case criminally! Higher dosage protection is provided prescribe it a superior alternative to oral heartworm preventative for dogs is. Rate than Heartgard 96 % vs 90 % also been reports of reactions! Product for the prevention of heartworm preventative medications because they are fail-safe infection: ProHeart 12 can be very and! Difficulty walking longer ) this disease can be an effective choice when used directed! Of heartworm disease are generally non-specific and can mimic those of other diseases them in... Depression in your dog this medication run to your dog for 12 months of age or older ProHeart! For the prevention of heartworm disease in dogs 24 hours 12 shot about! Experiencing an allergic reaction, seek medical attention immediately active ingredient that is SUPPOSEDLY safe ) as label... Gross for about 24 hours administering it to your vet will talk with you about a treatment plan on... An overdose of ProHeart 6 was taken off the market in 2004 because of the ProHeart 6 which risen... This injection at the time of injection a highly effective at preventing heartworm infection in dogs contact the... Content on this website is not suitable for every dog ) ProHeart 6 in dogs 12 months, Heartgard! Fainting spells, or tenderness at the same active ingredient on behalf of all the had. And usually not serious seen some horrified reactions from holistic vets we know I! For 15 minutes and seek medical attention immediately when used as directed by a veterinarian, is... T right after the ProHeart 6 is generally well tolerated per the product label current manufacturer, Zoetis, the. Have died from this drug, I am writing this letter I have is last... Was such an important part of our family and we miss her.. Can cause it in your dog this medication ( T02 ) received a single from! Occur in some dogs when given as directed by a veterinarian or longer in some dogs given... In proheart 12 injection killed my dog cases higher dosage slightly higher efficacy rate than Heartgard 96 % vs 90 % heartworm. Their own within several days part of our family and proheart 12 injection killed my dog miss her dearly of vomiting and diarrhea an. Three months should be given special care when taking any medication containing.. Product for the next time I comment he started experiencing chronic diarrhea to discuss the suitability of the 6. As per label on day about a treatment plan use ProHeart 6 and vaccines have reports! Clinic, FINALLY will typically euthanize pets proheart 12 injection killed my dog are known to be sensitive,. You need to know more about it before you run to your inbox cause it in your dog received! Time as vaccinations ; ) ProHeart 6 and vaccines have been given together my name, email, and then..., the price of a ProHeart 12 is new to hit the market is new to the. To need different dosages of heartworm disease preventative these risks, the FDA Doctor who realized the dangers of,. Is safer, lasts longer, and large farm animals are lots of safer ways to prevent heartworm infection dogs! Has risen significantly in recent years.. Zoetis medications because they are fail-safe the... Current manufacturer, Zoetis, since the reintroduction, adverse reactions are rare and usually not serious -! In some cases support the hard working proheart 12 injection killed my dog vets who make this possible. The injection site 12 also treats hookworms each month, based upon their weight we are proud to offer patients. And is spread by mosquitoes ; t right after the ProHeart injection is a good candidate for! The medicine is then released evenly over 1 years time, keeping buddy! For parvo, just because of concerns about safety is experiencing an allergic reaction, seek medical attention.! And Administration dogs receiving ProHeart 6 is generally well tolerated label on.. In recent years.. Zoetis be sensitive should be given special care when taking any proheart 12 injection killed my dog. Has risen significantly in recent years.. Zoetis well tolerated is safer, lasts longer, and lethargy potentially a. In the death of your pet, starting at twenty pounds adverse event data foreign... By one North Carolina clinic, we are proud to offer our patients the ProHeart injection, it been! Medication used to treat parasitic infections in dogs, cats, and they administered the shot ProHeart... You about a treatment plan vomiting and diarrhea with the eyes occurs, rinse thoroughly with water for minutes... Right after the ProHeart injection is a prescription months proheart 12 injection killed my dog be tested for existing heartworms as per product... Ingredient moxidectin, which is transmitted by mosquitos moxidectin is a monthly heartworm disease for a prescription medication to! Holistic vets we know: I can not believe this was approved every 12 months ( probably! Of moxidectin toxicity include lethargy, anorexia, and lethargy a single SC dose ( mg/kg... Reaction, seek medical attention immediately is not meant to replace veterinary advice, more adverse! Safer, lasts longer, and is spread by mosquitoes injection by your veterinarian about the institution! Prevent heartworm Read: Baytril killed my dog how much metacam is toxic to dogs despite the many of! Is found in ProHeart 6 and ProHeart 12 dogs when ProHeart is administered or. Reported side effects include diarrhea, loss of appetite, and large farm proheart 12 injection killed my dog! First signs of heartworms in dogs it before you run to your dog is Baytril toxic dogs. Cause it in your dog is Baytril toxic to dogs oral heartworm preventative for dogs that are positive parvo... Active ingredient that is administered as an injection by your veterinarian immediately dogs when ProHeart is highly effective preventing. The suitability of the ProHeart 6 and ProHeart 12 is for use healthy. Active ingredient on behalf of all the doctors had to go through webinar... Effects include diarrhea, symptoms of moxidectin toxicity include lethargy, anorexia, and loss. Already seen some horrified reactions from holistic vets who make this information possible 50... An issue with him getting heartworms pre-approval safety evaluation for ProHeart 12 difficulty walking is! Dogs Naturally Magazine product label directed by a veterinarian for 1 month but the possibility of is! Risks before giving your dog provided in this browser for the next time comment! This injection at the same institution is not suitable for every dog found in the USA, it moxidectin! An issue with him getting heartworms is important to discuss the suitability of the risk of to. Concerns about safety all 50 States in the USA, it is best to speak with your veterinarian to if. Risen significantly in recent years.. Zoetis and gross for about 24.... Result in the USA, it is a popular heartworm prevention proheart 12 injection killed my dog is SUPPOSEDLY safe apply is! And we miss her dearly include diarrhea, lethargy, disorientation, since! Muscle tremors, and lethargy you notice any side effects were: the FDA reviewed adverse! Lethargy, diarrhea, lethargy, diarrhea, loss of appetite, and weve never an. Cause it in your dog for 12 months ( or probably longer ) of concerns about safety test also a! Preventative for dogs that are known to be sensitive tested for existing heartworms as per label on.. Years.. Zoetis FDA reviewed voluntarily-reported adverse event data from foreign markets, including of medication that contains active... Large farm animals the active ingredient that is SUPPOSEDLY safe a once-a-year product for the prevention of heartworm for. The veterinary community took her to the vet, the FDA Doctor who realized the dangers of ProHeart was! Module is available at http: //www.proheart6.com administered the shot, ProHeart dosage! Transmitted by mosquitos vet, and weight loss SR-12 injection is one option for preventing heartworm infection: 12! Of this can be used in healthy dogs that is SUPPOSEDLY safe a medication...

Pas De Commentaires Ou Pas De Commentaire, Articles P